Brown Owl Substitute
Moderators: Ken M 44, joaniebo
Brown Owl Substitute
#1Anyone with a suggestion as to a decent substitute for brown owl hackles to use in tying Edmonds & Lee's "Brown Owl" (No. 11) soft hackle? Thanks.
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
Grant - See what I mean about the addiction ?
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
Grant - See what I mean about the addiction ?
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
- moregrayling
- Master Guide
- Posts: 857
- Joined: 10/07/05 18:00
Brown Owl Substitute
#2bob,
try hen dyed the correct shade (it's a reddish brown). the brown owl wings I've handled were rather grey, so even if you'd get hold of owl, it's difficult to get the correct shade.
best from krautland,
christian
try hen dyed the correct shade (it's a reddish brown). the brown owl wings I've handled were rather grey, so even if you'd get hold of owl, it's difficult to get the correct shade.
best from krautland,
christian
Best,
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Brown Owl Substitute
#3Christian After doing the above posting, I did find one suggestion (on Don Nicholson's site, I believe) to use French Partridge as a sub .... which I'll have to try ... plus see if any of my hen skins look close enough to the right color.
Best
BobPS - Just found some light, reddish-brown / grayish wing feathers on a hen skin that look great as a sub.
Best
BobPS - Just found some light, reddish-brown / grayish wing feathers on a hen skin that look great as a sub.
Last edited by joaniebo on 11/10/07 07:20, edited 1 time in total.
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
Brown Owl Substitute
#4Bob ... I know that you have a few of the real thing even if only for comparison
Brown Owl Substitute
#5Ken Check your e-mail for a comparison picture. Best Bob
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
Brown Owl Substitute
#6Bob - They are Very Very Very Cool
I have only found one way to obtain these feathers and it is not cheap ....
I have only found one way to obtain these feathers and it is not cheap ....
- DrLogik
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 3091
- Joined: 12/20/04 19:00
- Location: The Piedmont region in NC
- Contact:
Brown Owl Substitute
#7One question:
When the pattern calls for:
"The tail fhall be fparsely dreffed with the frefhest urine-burned under fur taken from th' nether regionf of a live Mastadon. Approach th' beaft with the utmoft caution so af to not caufe him angft..."
Wudya gonna to do then my friend?????
When the pattern calls for:
"The tail fhall be fparsely dreffed with the frefhest urine-burned under fur taken from th' nether regionf of a live Mastadon. Approach th' beaft with the utmoft caution so af to not caufe him angft..."
Wudya gonna to do then my friend?????
Brown Owl Substitute
#8Grant
If the pattern I wanted to tie had those instructions, I'd probably contact Ken and Christian for some assistance, as they probably have the specified materials readily available on their fly tying benches ! :>)
Best
Bob
If the pattern I wanted to tie had those instructions, I'd probably contact Ken and Christian for some assistance, as they probably have the specified materials readily available on their fly tying benches ! :>)
Best
Bob
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
Brown Owl Substitute
#9Bob - you are correct -
I have it on good authority that Christian's great great great great great great great (etc,) Grandfather was a master at sneaking up behind live mastodons and plucking bits from their nether regions.
I have it on good authority that Christian's great great great great great great great (etc,) Grandfather was a master at sneaking up behind live mastodons and plucking bits from their nether regions.
Brown Owl Substitute
#10Here are pics of substitute hackles used to tie a few of the Edmonds & Lee's pattern called "The Brown Owl". The top fly's hackle was a hen flank feather; the middle fly has a hen neck hackle (from the same bird); and the bottom fly has a French Partridge Hackle (the smallest I have available). Silk was Pearsall Gossamer #6a and the head is Bronze peacock. I look forward to seeing if the Cheese Country dace will enjoy this fly when the season re-opens next year.
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
PS - My camera takes lousy close-ups. So, in order to take the pics, I lay the flies on my flatbed scanner, closing the lid on top of them. Thus, the "flattened" shape of some soft hackles.
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
PS - My camera takes lousy close-ups. So, in order to take the pics, I lay the flies on my flatbed scanner, closing the lid on top of them. Thus, the "flattened" shape of some soft hackles.
Last edited by joaniebo on 11/15/07 05:03, edited 1 time in total.
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
- moregrayling
- Master Guide
- Posts: 857
- Joined: 10/07/05 18:00
Brown Owl Substitute
#11doc,DrLogik wrote:One question:
When the pattern calls for:
"The tail fhall be fparsely dreffed with the frefhest urine-burned under fur taken from th' nether regionf of a live Mastadon. Approach th' beaft with the utmoft caution so af to not caufe him angft..."
Wudya gonna to do then my friend?????
as it happens, I have several bags of the stuff at hand, which I inherited from my great great great great great great great (etc.) grandfather, so if you're interested, give me a buzz.
with the very best,
christian
Last edited by moregrayling on 11/14/07 10:13, edited 1 time in total.
Best,
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
-
- Master Guide
- Posts: 403
- Joined: 03/28/07 18:00
- DrLogik
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 3091
- Joined: 12/20/04 19:00
- Location: The Piedmont region in NC
- Contact:
Brown Owl Substitute
#13No. But I do have some Unicorn horn-bourne wax from the forlorned unicorn of yorn......
Brown Owl Substitute
#14Tried spotted owl as a substitute?Anyone with a suggestion as to a decent substitute for brown owl
Regards,
Martin in Sweden
Brown Owl Substitute
#15Martin
Thanks for the suggestion. Unfortunately, I don't have a source for any owl feathers. Guess I will have to settle for some brownish colored hen hackles.
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
Thanks for the suggestion. Unfortunately, I don't have a source for any owl feathers. Guess I will have to settle for some brownish colored hen hackles.
Cheers and Safe Fishing
Bob
"Fishing is such great fun, I have often felt, that it really ought to be done in bed." - John Voelker
- moregrayling
- Master Guide
- Posts: 857
- Joined: 10/07/05 18:00
Brown Owl Substitute
#17wsbailey wrote:I would suggest bob white quail. Bill
bill,
could you please post a pic of one or more feathers? thank you.
best from "krautland",
christian
Best,
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
- moregrayling
- Master Guide
- Posts: 857
- Joined: 10/07/05 18:00
Brown Owl Substitute
#19neat, cheers bill. I'd like to have a couple of wings the same colour as the nebrascan male. I wouldn't want to buy these blind though, not with that kind of variation in colour...
thanks again. best,
christian
Best,
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Christian
Them, that knows nowt, fears nowt!
Brown Owl Substitute
#20I know what you mean about buying blind. Blue Ribbon Flies does a great job of picking skins; at least they have always come through for me.
http://www.blueribbonflies.com/merchandise/flytying_birdskinfeathers.shtml
Bill
http://www.blueribbonflies.com/merchandise/flytying_birdskinfeathers.shtml
Bill