Wading boots
Moderators: pmcroberts, uniphasian
Wading boots
#1After far too many years and sore feet I bought a new pair of wading boots last fall. I debated hard on spending that many $$ on a pair of boots (yeah, I'm real cheap when its for myself) and whether rubber soles could possibly match the grip of felt on the slick rocks here in Colorado. However, after swallowing hard I bought a pair of Orvis Pros, with a rubber sole by Michelin.
One trip was all it took to make me smile. They are so much stickier than felt that it is amazing. Also great support and so comfortable. Happy camper here.
One trip was all it took to make me smile. They are so much stickier than felt that it is amazing. Also great support and so comfortable. Happy camper here.
Re: Wading boots
#2Glad to hear this - I just got a pair for myself after the sole of my Simms G3 came off 3/4 of a mile from the car. All 3 fly shops I spoke with had the highest regard for the Orvis pro boot with many of their staff and guides using it. Will see how long these last. They feel very lightweight and supportive - like a hiking boot.
Re: Wading boots
#3Ugh. I was having trouble staying on my feet with my G3's Vibram soles on northern WI freestoners, so I doubled down and bought a pair of G3 felts a couple weeks ago.
Thanks for the recommendation, I'll lock this in the memory bank.
Thanks for the recommendation, I'll lock this in the memory bank.
Re: Wading boots
#4The Simms vibram soles for me are too slippery. Interesting to hear about the Orvis soles. I may have to give them a try.
Jake
Jake
Re: Wading boots
#6Both Simms mad Patagonia rubber soles were way too slippery for me (remember Mark?).
Unless full with studs (at least 10 per shoe and not just 6 as the first fly shop advised me) it’s a no go for me.
I too prefer felt over rubber (even with studs) any time
Unless full with studs (at least 10 per shoe and not just 6 as the first fly shop advised me) it’s a no go for me.
I too prefer felt over rubber (even with studs) any time
Re: Wading boots
#7Felts are great in the water but in my experience don't perform well out of water - muddy banks, snow build up, etc Hope the orvis tread works well in both environments.
Re: Wading boots
#8Nothing beats felt in slippery freestone streams. I've tried the "sticky rubber" boots, not even close. My concern is bite in the stream, not out.
Until one has loved an animal a part of one's soul remains unawakened.
Anatole France
Anatole France
Re: Wading boots
#9Thanks for the recommendation / review. I have been happy with all the Simms boots I have purchased with the exception of one pair with the BOA system. I did not like it, not a good fit for me plus the cable broke too soon. My friend loves his Orvis and they look good, but he has the BOA model.
Hopefully I am not in the market for boots for a while, but will check Orvis.
I have not used felt for many years, but rely on a wading staff when the Vibrant soles fall short...
Tight Lines
Hopefully I am not in the market for boots for a while, but will check Orvis.
I have not used felt for many years, but rely on a wading staff when the Vibrant soles fall short...
Tight Lines
Re: Wading boots
#10I'm a fan of the Orvis PRO with Michelin soles. They are stickier for me than all other rubber soles, including Vibram. When it comes to felts, I love the Chotas, which have much more durable and are stickier than the various felts I've used over the years. I think the felt is made from a synthetic like polypropylene, and they dry off faster.
tl
les
tl
les
Re: Wading boots
#11Hi Alex, agree on the BOA system. Regarding the G3's Vibram soles, I've found they work well on the limestone cobble we have in the Driftless, but are next to worthless on the glacial freestoners up north -- though they are good for hiking in and out. I have both aluminum and carbide cleats on mine and it doesn't help up there. Hoping the felts on the new G3's are as good as previous (studded) felts I've owned, those were pretty dependable both on the northern streams and out west.AlexP wrote: ↑01/07/22 10:43Thanks for the recommendation / review. I have been happy with all the Simms boots I have purchased with the exception of one pair with the BOA system. I did not like it, not a good fit for me plus the cable broke too soon. My friend loves his Orvis and they look good, but he has the BOA model.
Hopefully I am not in the market for boots for a while, but will check Orvis.
I have not used felt for many years, but rely on a wading staff when the Vibrant soles fall short...
Tight Lines
I've heard great things about the Chotas -- their felt supposedly sticks like no other.
- Greg Reynolds
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 3087
- Joined: 12/21/04 19:00
- Location: The Laurel Highlands, PA
Re: Wading boots
#13I have two pairs of Simms Freestone boots with Vibram soles fitted a combination of Simms carbide studs and carbide star cleats. I've used them on varied substrates ranging from large cobbles to smooth slate and like them far more than felt. I've been using them since 2013 and like them enough to have a third new pair sitting in reserve.
The Orvis Database: http://antiquerodandreels.com/databases/orvisdb
Re: Wading boots
#14For me the Orvis Michelin rubber is far better in freestone streams than felt. My wife has Simms Vibram soles, but thinks that the Orvis rubber is probably stickier in the water.
Re: Wading boots
#15I personally have not used them. I don't purchase rubber soles anymore, felt only. I have a fishing buddy who has the Orvis boots, while he says they are by far the best rubber soles he has owned, and he is happy with them, he will tell you they are not superior to felt in tricky slick rocky streams.
Until one has loved an animal a part of one's soul remains unawakened.
Anatole France
Anatole France
-
- Master Guide
- Posts: 435
- Joined: 12/06/15 19:29
- Contact:
Re: Wading boots
#16Yes Sir Cappy I agree with you 100% bought Orvis wading boots rubber soles supposed to have superior traction first rubber sole wading boots I’ve every used, it only took one outing to convince me that no way is rubber better than felt, I proceeded to install 2 layers of indoor/outdoor carpet as we used to do years ago, very good traction now, as far as boot fit and boot integrety, excellant the sides are rigid, you don’t have to worry about having your foot jammed between 2 rocks and killing your toes.
- Kai Larson
- Sport
- Posts: 31
- Joined: 01/13/12 22:52
- Location: Utah
- Contact:
Re: Wading boots
#17Try one of the wading boots with aluminum bars riveted to the soles.
My guess is that you will never go back to any other sole type.
My guess is that you will never go back to any other sole type.
Re: Wading boots
#18+1 on the Chotas. Felts with studs is the apex of good fishing traction. They don't seem like popular boots; I never see anyone besides me wearing them.lestrout1 wrote: ↑01/07/22 14:21I'm a fan of the Orvis PRO with Michelin soles. They are stickier for me than all other rubber soles, including Vibram. When it comes to felts, I love the Chotas, which have much more durable and are stickier than the various felts I've used over the years. I think the felt is made from a synthetic like polypropylene, and they dry off faster.
tl
les
Re: Wading boots
#19Chotas are all I use. My last purchase was three pair when I found them at a could not pass up price. Still have two pair in boxes.billems wrote: ↑01/08/22 14:53+1 on the Chotas. Felts with studs is the apex of good fishing traction. They don't seem like popular boots; I never see anyone besides me wearing them.lestrout1 wrote: ↑01/07/22 14:21I'm a fan of the Orvis PRO with Michelin soles. They are stickier for me than all other rubber soles, including Vibram. When it comes to felts, I love the Chotas, which have much more durable and are stickier than the various felts I've used over the years. I think the felt is made from a synthetic like polypropylene, and they dry off faster.
tl
les
With regards to studs I didn't like the feel on large rocks. Straight felt for me.
Until one has loved an animal a part of one's soul remains unawakened.
Anatole France
Anatole France
- JohnMD1022
- Master Guide
- Posts: 373
- Joined: 10/02/09 18:00
- Location: Maryland
- Contact:
Re: Wading boots
#20Felt has been banned in Maryland and at least 6 other states.
No felt soles are allowed in Yellowstone Park.
As I am on the brink of turning 80, I confine my wading to spring creeks. All I need are a pair of cheap, high-top sneakers from Walmart. I prefer the Velcro ones.
No felt soles are allowed in Yellowstone Park.
As I am on the brink of turning 80, I confine my wading to spring creeks. All I need are a pair of cheap, high-top sneakers from Walmart. I prefer the Velcro ones.