I have finally found perhaps the absolute worst book on nymph fishing ever. In its defense, it may well be because of the translation into English but wow! This bugger is rough. It's not only verbose but contradicts itself throughout. Talk about splitting hairs and beating a subject to death on various topics, whoa. It was a complete choir to plow through this one. The book is "Chech Nymph & Other Related Fly-Fishing Methods" by Mr. Karel Krivanec et al. Published in 2007 by Grayling & Trout Publishing. So, if you are a serious nymph fisherman and happen to cross paths with this book run for cover and start drinking heavily.
Mark
I have finally found it! :(
Moderator: Whitefish Press
- Hellmtflies
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 8061
- Joined: 01/14/12 10:27
- Location: Bozeman, Montana
- creakycane
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 3882
- Joined: 06/20/06 18:00
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#2The competition is often stiff when trying to find the “worst” book on an aspect of fly fishing. While there are typically many good ones, there are tons of poor to terrible books. I would say that half of the new flyfishing books are poorly written and/or repetitive rubbish. Technique books really suffer, since it is much easier to look up something on YouTube that try to decipher a howto book on most topics.
Karel’s Book does have translation issues, but it is a pattern book with a sprinkling of technique (in my mind). The nymphs he talks about are found in many Eastern European fly shops, along with hundreds of other Czech style nymphs. The two shops a short walk east from historic Prague carry them all. I bought a bunch, just because, but only have put them to limited use. To me, it’s like looking at a hundreds of variations of a brassie nymph. Only so interesting, IMO. Do we really need all those patterns? The Czech nymph Angler must think so.
The book was somewhat novel when published, but not one I would reread.
There have been better books written on the subject after Karel’s, in English, that are readily available, though some lack citations and credit to originators of Czech/Polish/French/Spanish techniques. I mean, if you are going to publish a book involving, say, French nymphing, you would think you would want some links back to originators and primary sources in , oh, I don’t know, France perhaps?.... maybe some semi original pictures, instead of same old publisher stock photos of northeastern trout sTreams....
Karel’s book doesn’t have to do that, since Karel and his associates are some of those originators ( or at least a generation or two removed from these originators)..
Karel’s other book on the Grayling paradise of the Vltava River is more interesting, and worth a look. I used it to plan a trip at one point and the info was very helpful and accurate. For maps, go to google!
Karel’s Book does have translation issues, but it is a pattern book with a sprinkling of technique (in my mind). The nymphs he talks about are found in many Eastern European fly shops, along with hundreds of other Czech style nymphs. The two shops a short walk east from historic Prague carry them all. I bought a bunch, just because, but only have put them to limited use. To me, it’s like looking at a hundreds of variations of a brassie nymph. Only so interesting, IMO. Do we really need all those patterns? The Czech nymph Angler must think so.
The book was somewhat novel when published, but not one I would reread.
There have been better books written on the subject after Karel’s, in English, that are readily available, though some lack citations and credit to originators of Czech/Polish/French/Spanish techniques. I mean, if you are going to publish a book involving, say, French nymphing, you would think you would want some links back to originators and primary sources in , oh, I don’t know, France perhaps?.... maybe some semi original pictures, instead of same old publisher stock photos of northeastern trout sTreams....
Karel’s book doesn’t have to do that, since Karel and his associates are some of those originators ( or at least a generation or two removed from these originators)..
Karel’s other book on the Grayling paradise of the Vltava River is more interesting, and worth a look. I used it to plan a trip at one point and the info was very helpful and accurate. For maps, go to google!
Last edited by creakycane on 04/18/22 13:54, edited 1 time in total.
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#3Sounds like what one should suspect when trying to read a book on nymph fishing. I recently donated a new condition G.D. book on same to CFFCM, an unsolicited review copy from several years back in my newspaper days. I tried when I got it but found it unreadable.
...a wink of gold like the glint of sunlight on polished cane...
brightwatercatskill.art.blog
brightwatercatskill.art.blog
- flyslinger
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 1026
- Joined: 05/30/07 18:00
- Location: Beautiful downtown Glenn Springs, Tx.
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#5Could be worse. You could have tried to read "Flyfishing Through The Mid Life Crisis".
"Always drink upstream from the herd."
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#6Oh no flyslinger, not that!
...a wink of gold like the glint of sunlight on polished cane...
brightwatercatskill.art.blog
brightwatercatskill.art.blog
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#7Here's a book I want to see published: "Nymphing without Beads or Indicators," by Ned Neverketchm.
- JohnMD1022
- Master Guide
- Posts: 379
- Joined: 10/02/09 18:00
- Location: Maryland
- Contact:
Re: I have finally found it! :(
#8It is bad, no question. If I were at home, I could suggest several others to avoid, but that one is slated for the next round of Little Free Library rounds.flyslinger wrote: ↑04/17/22 16:42Could be worse. You could have tried to read "Flyfishing Through The Mid Life Crisis".
Let someone else suffer.