A P Lodge name or model
Moderator: TheMontyMan
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
A P Lodge name or model
#1I have a rod that defiantly needs work, but the shape of the cork and the flared bamboo taper at the but end interest me. The only identification is "A P Lodge" painted at the but end. I do not see any indication of the maker. It is a 3 piece, 9'-0" long rod. I'm thinking about making an attempt to restore it, but have limited experience and thought that I should know what it is before changing anything.
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#2Hi Guys, Interesting rod, but I have zero idea about it. Someone here will though. It needs at least some cosmetic work.
Jay Edwards
Jay Edwards
-
- Master Guide
- Posts: 441
- Joined: 07/22/20 18:38
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#3I believe your rod is an early Union Hardware rod.
Previously known as bamboocollector11
- steeliefool
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 1675
- Joined: 09/07/16 15:28
- Location: Jersey
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#5I have looked at some of the other conversations on Union Hardware bamboo rods. Looks like they were made back into the 20's with their own production and some by Montague. How early in their production are you suspecting? What does the "+1 The winding check" mean? Is it just one of many rods made or is there any historic or monitory value to the rod?
If I do work on it, the first guide is missing. Would like to find out if it would have been a wire snake or agate.
If I do work on it, the first guide is missing. Would like to find out if it would have been a wire snake or agate.
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#6My first impression, also. The winding check and grip profile are unique, but I know I have seen them before. I feel the name on the rod is simply the owner's.
As for the stripping guide, unless the tip has an agate (or 'agatine') tiptop, I would mount a Mildrum style guide for the stripper. It was common, though not a rule, for factories to mount agates in pairs, i.e. tiptop and stripper. It was an extra cost option on some makers' price lists. Synthetic agates,such as glass, were commonly used by the big factories on higher grades.
"+1" is forum speak for 'ditto'.
- steeliefool
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 1675
- Joined: 09/07/16 15:28
- Location: Jersey
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#7Thanks Jeff!
The "winding check" is the metal bit just above the cork handle, the "tell" for me and is the same as this one on a UH built Thos E Wilson rod I own although yours appears to be partly overwrapped with thread.
And here's the reel seat(the part that hold the reel just below the cork handle) on the same rod.
The Union Hardware Co. of Torrington, CT was noted as a manufacturer of fishing reels and delved into the rod market in competition with the likes of Montague whose hardware was “mimicked” to make Union Hardware’s product more acceptable to the fishing public and retailers. Rarely marked with the company name, most rods were built for the trade and retailed by many.
My rod was built sometime before 1925 the year when Thos E. merged with a sporting goods company, expanded their line of products and initiated a name change.
The "winding check" is the metal bit just above the cork handle, the "tell" for me and is the same as this one on a UH built Thos E Wilson rod I own although yours appears to be partly overwrapped with thread.
And here's the reel seat(the part that hold the reel just below the cork handle) on the same rod.
The Union Hardware Co. of Torrington, CT was noted as a manufacturer of fishing reels and delved into the rod market in competition with the likes of Montague whose hardware was “mimicked” to make Union Hardware’s product more acceptable to the fishing public and retailers. Rarely marked with the company name, most rods were built for the trade and retailed by many.
My rod was built sometime before 1925 the year when Thos E. merged with a sporting goods company, expanded their line of products and initiated a name change.
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#8Both of those pieces are similar, but there are differences. The Winding check return area to the cork is very straight, no outward flair. Also it does not appear to be wound over. The hexagonal shape of the bamboo extends right up to the face of the winding check. The reel seat is more similar, but still different. The socket for the back of the reel is formed as part of the metal cap that forms the end of the seat. Also the forward end of the seat has a band of fine diagonal hatch instead of just two parallel grooves.
- TheMontyMan
- Global Moderator
- Posts: 1703
- Joined: 03/13/09 19:00
- Location: Pacific NW
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#10Definitely a Union Hardware built rod, most likely built in the mid- to late 1920's.
There are typical Union Hardware style traits on this rod's ferrules, winding check and reel seat. Many of Union Hardware's reel seats of this styling had that type of knurling pattern, an inch or so below the cork grip. If Montague added knurling on a reel seat of this style, it would typically be up close to the cork grip.
That said, every bamboo rod is special and a hand crafted work of art, even if machines were involved in the production. Your rod appears to have some nice, high-end qualities, and would probably fish nicely with a little TLC.
. . . Rex
The Monty Man
There are typical Union Hardware style traits on this rod's ferrules, winding check and reel seat. Many of Union Hardware's reel seats of this styling had that type of knurling pattern, an inch or so below the cork grip. If Montague added knurling on a reel seat of this style, it would typically be up close to the cork grip.
Union Hardware had a very sizeable factory and produced bamboo rods by the hundreds or even thousands per day. Most of their rod "models" were built in large batches to be sold to multiple wholesalers or retailers. Additionally an individual "model" may have been built basically the same way for years. That means this rod is probably not particularly special or rare and not many people are heavily into collecting Union Hardware rods.SouthBrZar wrote:Is it just one of many rods made or is there any historic or monitory value to the rod?
That said, every bamboo rod is special and a hand crafted work of art, even if machines were involved in the production. Your rod appears to have some nice, high-end qualities, and would probably fish nicely with a little TLC.
. . . Rex
The Monty Man
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#11Thanks to all of you for the information and taking time to analyze and respond.
I agree with and appreciate the closing comment from Rex, "That said, every bamboo rod is special and a hand crafted work of art, even if machines were involved in the production. Your rod appears to have some nice, high-end qualities, and would probably fish nicely with a little TLC."
I agree with and appreciate the closing comment from Rex, "That said, every bamboo rod is special and a hand crafted work of art, even if machines were involved in the production. Your rod appears to have some nice, high-end qualities, and would probably fish nicely with a little TLC."
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#12This is the only other reference to an A P Lodge bamboo fly rod that I have found. The site no longer has the thread on this question as far as I can tell. The name and rod length match, so I am guessing that it is not the owners name. Rather a model name, actual lodge, or something of the sort that they produced rods for.
- TheMontyMan
- Global Moderator
- Posts: 1703
- Joined: 03/13/09 19:00
- Location: Pacific NW
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#13It appears that post on the Joes Old Lures message board was posted 10 months ago, or longer. How long have you had this rod?
The posted rod may have been the same rod as you have now, if you recently acquired it.
Well, this is why I like to see a lot of rods posted for identification... I started to post this -
This example is a fairly smooth, fancy script with quotes (similar to Montague's typical scripting)
viewtopic.php?p=576634&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p576634
This example is done in block lettering
viewtopic.php?p=590960&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p590960
This one is what I would consider "typical" Union Hardware scripting. A majority of the scripted Union Hardware rods that I've seen resembled this styling
viewtopic.php?p=643477&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p643477
So, my newest, latest, greatest opinion (that could change again tomorrow) is that Union Hardware was not very consistent in the hand scripted labeling of their rods over time. So there's a good chance the scripting was applied by Union Hardware, but we may never know for sure. If we had 2 or 3 similar instances it would be easier to narrow it down to the maker or the retailer.
This exercise reinforces the great value of this Forum as the premier source of information about vintage bamboo fly rods. Thanks to all who contribute! And a special thanks to those of you who research before posting!
. . . Rex
The Monty Man
The posted rod may have been the same rod as you have now, if you recently acquired it.
Well, this is why I like to see a lot of rods posted for identification... I started to post this -
- The "A P Lodge" script on the rod doesn't look like typical Union Hardware shop applied scripting. It looks too smooth, fancy and thin lined compared to their typical hand scripted styling, so I don't think it's likely it was applied by Union Hardware. It was more likely applied by the retailer or by the owner.
This example is a fairly smooth, fancy script with quotes (similar to Montague's typical scripting)
viewtopic.php?p=576634&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p576634
This example is done in block lettering
viewtopic.php?p=590960&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p590960
This one is what I would consider "typical" Union Hardware scripting. A majority of the scripted Union Hardware rods that I've seen resembled this styling
viewtopic.php?p=643477&hilit=union+hard ... pt#p643477
So, my newest, latest, greatest opinion (that could change again tomorrow) is that Union Hardware was not very consistent in the hand scripted labeling of their rods over time. So there's a good chance the scripting was applied by Union Hardware, but we may never know for sure. If we had 2 or 3 similar instances it would be easier to narrow it down to the maker or the retailer.
This exercise reinforces the great value of this Forum as the premier source of information about vintage bamboo fly rods. Thanks to all who contribute! And a special thanks to those of you who research before posting!
. . . Rex
The Monty Man
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#14I have had it for at least 5 years and mine is defiantly not in the good condition that they are describing. The script is applied under the finish, directly on the bamboo. I would interpret that as being applied by the maker, unless they were sending out unfinished rods.
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#15The first of these 3 examples matches my rod in more ways than just the script. The script is very close, more than just being smooth and fancy. First letters have an exaggerated tilt to them and lower case are more vertical. The sweeping line leading into the leading letters. The reel seat and cork look to be an exact match. The Winding check has the same straight line to it and the texture/spacing of the texture has the same fine design. The earlier post that some of it may have been wound over could be correct.
-
- Member
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 01/23/23 10:45
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#16Based on the previous rod review that had many similarities I decided to check for the ramped machined ferrule feature.
My rod needs to be rewrapped and finished anyway so I cut the winding off at one of the ferrules. It defiantly has the ramped machined ferrule. The ferrule also seems to be cleaning up extremely well. Does that indicate that it is NiS?
My rod needs to be rewrapped and finished anyway so I cut the winding off at one of the ferrules. It defiantly has the ramped machined ferrule. The ferrule also seems to be cleaning up extremely well. Does that indicate that it is NiS?
Re: A P Lodge name or model
#17Good news- looks like NS
Bad news- it's drawn, not machined, a cost issue
To the average angler, it won't make any difference. Leonards, Thomases, Edwards, and some others have machined ferrules. Most South Bends (not all models), most Montagues(not all), and most H-Is (not all) have drawn ferrules. As long as they're kept clean, and the integrity of the mount is maintained, the average angler will be fine. Neglect them and all bets are off.
Bad news- it's drawn, not machined, a cost issue
To the average angler, it won't make any difference. Leonards, Thomases, Edwards, and some others have machined ferrules. Most South Bends (not all models), most Montagues(not all), and most H-Is (not all) have drawn ferrules. As long as they're kept clean, and the integrity of the mount is maintained, the average angler will be fine. Neglect them and all bets are off.