Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
Moderator: Whitefish Press
Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#1John Gierach is the best writer in the sport. No question. But the Trout Bum became a success, and some of his later stories involving private water, ritzy lodges, and locales that plebians like myself will never see, sometimes left me a bit sad and missing the bum. There is a story in his new book--I don't have it with me so forgot the chapter--where he addresses the matter, and though i can't quote him, he acknowledges that he's sometimes gone out of his element. Just that little confession warmed me back up to him. What a fine writer, essayist, sportsman is John Gierach.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#2I can’t imagine fishing like a high roller on private waters and upscale lodges and then presenting myself as a “bum.” Must be difficult.
-
- Guide
- Posts: 140
- Joined: 02/21/23 22:45
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#3He's still a friend to trout and those who like to poke holes in their mouths. "Bum" is a loose word, no need to take it the harshest way. When we can't fish, it's fun to read about it, and certainly JG (who, despite the "JG", I've never met or will) gets some points for his writing on bamboo, and his loyalty to it. How many others, "relics from the past" or whatever, have now signed on with graphite firms? Many. I vote for JG, and forgive any momentary lapse of perspective by anybody.
- DrLogik
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 3091
- Joined: 12/20/04 19:00
- Location: The Piedmont region in NC
- Contact:
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#4I see nothing wrong with a man who turned an ability to write about fly fishing into not just an occupation but made good living and achieved fame doing it. He is the ultimate Trout bum. "Bum" is not a derogatory term. It is a way of life for some people; however, 99% of those people struggle financially. Gierach found a lucrative way to support his bumming, and he does it with gracious and entertaining aplomb.
I'm also a real fan of the famous extreme skier Glen Plake. He's the guy with the crazy 2 foot high brightly colored and flattened mohawk hair style. He also found a way to make a living bumming, by skiing. He's the ultimate ski bum and has starred in many ski movies.
Can you imagine making a good living doing this every day? Oh man, count me in!
I'm also a real fan of the famous extreme skier Glen Plake. He's the guy with the crazy 2 foot high brightly colored and flattened mohawk hair style. He also found a way to make a living bumming, by skiing. He's the ultimate ski bum and has starred in many ski movies.
Can you imagine making a good living doing this every day? Oh man, count me in!
-
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 1686
- Joined: 11/12/05 19:00
- Location: Homosassa Fl
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#5Don't remember Gierach fishing like a high roller in his early works. He's paid his dues, inspired a lot of people along the way and deserves whatever benefits he gets from being so well known for his works. He's brought lots of enjoyable reading to those of us who can't live the life he has. More power to him and as always looking forward to his next book.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#7Wonderful photo of JG DrLogik. Interesting to note that he casts and winds with the same hand.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#8The book 'Trout Bum' was published in 1986 helping to establish JG's career as a writer. In many of his early woks he mentions making financial choices to support his hobby (like driving a beater truck to afford a couple of bamboo fly rods). There are many people in the fly fishing industry that would rather spend their hard earned $ on a fishing trip than a prestigious car or home (he never had a family). Many fishing journalists deduct their trip costs as a business expense.
I enjoy reading his stories.
An acquaintance I know recently had a grandson (actually his daughter did most of the work). I told him children are there for old men. Who else is going to say 'Grandpa, can I hear the story about you saving grandma from the chipmunk again'. I think if John Gierach told a story about saving a woman from a chipmunk it would be requested to be heard many times, laughing harder each time it was recited.
I enjoy reading his stories.
An acquaintance I know recently had a grandson (actually his daughter did most of the work). I told him children are there for old men. Who else is going to say 'Grandpa, can I hear the story about you saving grandma from the chipmunk again'. I think if John Gierach told a story about saving a woman from a chipmunk it would be requested to be heard many times, laughing harder each time it was recited.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#10Very respectable profession (as is being a well received writer). I will take a WAG and say JG's best year of book publishing to a niche market generated income half of a successful medical doctor. Certainly, better than his early days in Colorodo that contributed to the Trout Bum collection.I drove a beater so I could help pay for med school.
Thomas McGuane, as a novelist, probably generated much larger income. I recently re-read some of 'The Longest Silence' stories. IMO: McGuane's essays reflect the content of all too many magazine articles. When you are done reading the story I was left with the feeling that McGaune was simply looking for an excuse to tell people about an extremely big fish he caught. I don't get that feeling from most of JG's short stories.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#11I enjoy Gierach’s books very much.
Through his career we have seen him evolve as a writer and as a fly fisherman. I also have a few early books on audio which Gierach read himself which I listen to every once in a while.
Lou
Through his career we have seen him evolve as a writer and as a fly fisherman. I also have a few early books on audio which Gierach read himself which I listen to every once in a while.
Lou
In sport, method is everything. The more the skill the method calls for, the higher its yield of emotional stir and satisfaction, the higher its place must be in a sportsman’s scale of values . RODERICK HAIG - BROWN
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#12I wouldn't trade my life for JG either, but what working stiff who's struggling to support a family, and who endures all of the pressures that go with it, doesn't fantasize about doing nothing but fish all day or dropping everything and taking a trip across the country to chase trout? I wouldn't give up the fruits of my own labors, or my wife and children to be a true trout bum, but it's fun to read about it. Good for him that he found success while entertaining us.
-
- Bamboo Fanatic
- Posts: 1686
- Joined: 11/12/05 19:00
- Location: Homosassa Fl
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#13Funny how people who wouldn't want his life retire and upend their lives entirely to chase fish.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#14What’s wrong with that?GRASSNGLASS wrote: ↑05/17/23 12:05Funny how people who wouldn't want his life retire and upend their lives entirely to chase fish.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#15A lot of this just proves that a fundamental tenant of life is about choices and how those choices steer us. I heard a truism lately that said it very nicely, "A goal without a plan is a dream." I suspect the most successful among us understand that and plan accordingly.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#16My best friend in the world started off guiding in Wyo and Montana, moved on to Alaska, Chile, Little Cayman in the off season, among others. He then owned a fly shop in Saratoga, Wyo, sold that and now reps 10+ companies in the industry and spends his winters in Louisiana catching Reds and then the Keys fishing for all of the salt species. I have a career with a pension and 401k, a wife with the same and a 22 year old son that just graduated and has his ME and an MBA. We BOTH envy each others life, but are very happy with the one that we have. Thankfully I do have 5 weeks vacation to get my fix!
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#17I have always enjoyed Gierach’s style of writing and since his home water is my home water can relate to his prose. His latest book is no exception. It immortalized the pandemics effects on his choices.
Randy
Mead, CO.
Mead, CO.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#18Let's not fool ourselves, writing to the scale he has to carve out the life he has is hard work. Never begrudge anyone making money doing what they love and working hard at it.
Personally I've always have like all of his books too. I find him much more interesting because his books have ebbed and flowed with his lifestyle rather than remaining cookie cutter.
Personally I've always have like all of his books too. I find him much more interesting because his books have ebbed and flowed with his lifestyle rather than remaining cookie cutter.
- j.robillard
- Guide
- Posts: 232
- Joined: 09/14/21 14:20
- Location: Portland
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#19Yup, what he said.Drossi wrote: ↑05/23/23 13:28Let's not fool ourselves, writing to the scale he has to carve out the life he has is hard work. Never begrudge anyone making money doing what they love and working hard at it.
Personally I've always have like all of his books too. I find him much more interesting because his books have ebbed and flowed with his lifestyle rather than remaining cookie cutter.
The fly rod not only catches trout; it is a handy fulcrum allowing me to cast to those things that seem so far beyond my grasp.
-Harry Middleton.
-Harry Middleton.
Re: Gierach's "All the Time in the World."
#20I enjoyed the book. I had the opportunity to fish with John, Ed Engle and AK Best a free years ago in Montana. AK had brought his papers to the Bud Lilly Collection and I had the opportunity of showing them the Madison and a side branch off the Madison. John hooked and landed a brown pulling a wooly bugger. It was a cold and windy spring day