This should be interesting.
Chris
| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
cdmoore |
Your Top 10 (or so) Most Important Fly Fishing Books Of All Time |
Lead | ||
|
From the Treatise to Walton to McLean to Gierach to Drewett to Jennings to Garrison/Carmichael--in your opinion, what are the 10 most important books in the
world of fly fishing (or angling more generally if necessary). Slightly more or less than 10 acceptable and they don't need to be in any particular order.
Please give a brief reason why you chose each book on your list. And if there is a particular printing or edition that you especially favor, please include
that as well. If you want to swap out book for treatise, pamphlet, article, or whatever, that's fine, too.
This should be interesting. Chris
"If you finish in 7 days, I'll pay you for 10. If you finish in 10 days, I'll pay you for 7." ~Ballykissangel
|
||||
|
|
||||
Flyman615 |
OK, I'll try | #1 | ||
|
FWIW, here are 10 that most influenced me:
* "Trout" by Schwiebert. First "brown" edition. Don't nitpick it. It is a HUGE benchmark that likely never will be exceeded AND he was his own illustrator. * "Trout Madness" by Traver (aka Voelker). First edition. Simply terrific and most empathetic. * "Trout Bum" by Gierach. First edition (he just signed mine last weekend!) The new standard for fly fishing books of the 90's. * "Trout" by Bergman. Second edition is the best sized volume. Just as useful now as in 1938. * "Spring Creek" by Lyons. First edition. One of my all-time favorite "modern" writers. * "Where the Pools are Bright and Deep" by Lamb. First edition. An artist-like author. * "Trout Waters and How to Fish Them" by Bates. First edition. Another "learning moment" from 1949. * "Classic Rods and Rodmakers" by Keane. First edition. A seminal work for sure. Need I say more? * "Itchen Memories" by Skues. First edition. Makes me wish I'd been fishing in southern England after WWI. * "Fishing Bamboo" by Gierach. First edition. He likes to fish Grangers and so do I. He signed this one for me too.
Regards,
Flyman "There are three things in life that people like to stare at: a flowing stream, a crackling fire and a Zamboni clearing the ice."-Charlie Brown
Last Edited By: Flyman615 08/13/2009 19:35.
Edited 6 times.
|
||||
|
|
||||
leatherneck |
#2 | |||
|
Flyman, same books, same order except "Itchen Memories" which I would replace with "A Fly Fisher's Life" by Charles Ritz. That was easy. "The rule is perfect: in all matters of
opinion our adversaries are insane."
|
||||
|
|
||||
cdmoore |
Favorite or most important? | #3 | ||
|
Hi guys. Thanks for the insightful responses. Just to clarify, though, are you saying these 10 books are the most important books of all time on this topic, or
your favorites? Or both, and maybe because they are your favorites? I'm really looking for the 10 books which you think have had the most impact on the
sport (or means of eating) across the ages, plus why you think so. If that is what you have written down, then perfect! Thanks again, Chris
"If you finish in 7 days, I'll pay you for 10. If you finish in 10 days, I'll pay you for 7." ~Ballykissangel
|
||||
|
|
||||
mer |
#4 | |||
|
Thanks Chris. You've somehow managed to give me a homework assignment. I can't do it without looking at my bookcase
A partial list, without the reasons off the top of my head: Trout by Bergman Dry fly and fast water by LaBranche Rough stream nymph by Lawrie A fly fishers life by Ritz A Trout and Salmon Fisherman for 75 years by Hewitt (may not be the exact title) Men I have Fished with (can't recall author off hand) I have to come up with the exact titles but something by: Preston Jennings Art Flick Lee Wulff (probably his Atlantic Salmon book) John Alden Knight Ed Koch (one on midge fishing) Vince Marinaro one of the Cross/Dette/Darbee books on tying Catskill flies Roderick Haig-Brown (just about any one would do here)
This signature left intentionally blank.
|
||||
|
|
||||
cdmoore |
Sure | #5 | ||
|
I just wanted to avoid a "My Favorite Fly Fishing Books" post and challenge people to really think about what books out there have had a huge impact.
I haven't read all the books on the lists above and 500+ years is a long span. The world has changed a lot during that time, so any modern book could be
on the list: there are lots more fly fishers today than in the mid-1700s. How many people did A River Runs Through It reach before and after
the movie, or the fact that it was a movie--incredible, really? Or Trout. Or LaFontaine's
books on fly design...one of the first people to dawn a mask and figure out what it really looks like under there. Many folks, myself included, haven't
read the old books, or at least not many of them, so how much impact did they have? Yet the Treatise was about the only book going for almost 200 years, one
of the first printed books in the English language, and maybe the forerunner of all the others. Or how about the tide turning on the wet fly and nymphs with
the development of dries? How much rod design did those books inspire...was that the impetus for graphite? Or was it one of the "travel" books that
regaled us with tales of fly fishing the wide world that inspired the globalization of modern fly fishing? Or was it the first book that lay the foundation
for a catch & release ethic? I would like to constrain it to books that specifically turn around fly fishing in some way, which is to say that one
shouldn't include the first known book, or the Bible, or Silent Spring...unless you could make a convincing argument for a fly fishing reference.
Oh, and this is not limited to English language. If you have one from another source...say German...or Japanese (think: tenkara)...or Macedonian...bring it.
The Easton Press collection might be a good starting point. Something like this discussion must have occurred in the publisher's office. But they printed
more than 10. Thanks...it's starting to get interesting.
"If you finish in 7 days, I'll pay you for 10. If you finish in 10 days, I'll pay you for 7." ~Ballykissangel
|
||||
|
|
||||
Flyman615 |
#6 | |||
|
IMO, everyone has a different perspective on The 10 Most Impactive Fly Fishing Books of All Time because not only does everyone have their own
areas of interest, but because over 2000 fly fishing titles (or is it 3000?) have been published, it's pretty much impossible for one person to have read
them all.
Therefore, I included on my list only influential books I have personally read. That is, as opposed to supposedly impactive books I have read about, which may or may not live up to their respective reputations.
Regards,
Flyman "There are three things in life that people like to stare at: a flowing stream, a crackling fire and a Zamboni clearing the ice."-Charlie Brown
Last Edited By: Flyman615 08/13/2009 10:12.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
quashnet |
#7 | |||
|
Because angling is so broad an experience, ten books are too few, even if we stay only with the English language and make no mention of volumes like Fernando
Basurto's 1539 book on Spanish fly fishing, which predates Walton. But a most-important list might at least include the following:
Dame Juliana Berners, The Treatise of Fishing with an Angle, 1496. Defined fishing as a sport, and was the word on the subject for the next two centuries. Izaak Walton and Charles Cotton, The Compleat Angler, 1676. Walton for the reasons why we fish, and Cotton so that we can "fish fine and far off." William Scrope, Days and Nights of Salmon Fishing in the Tweed, 1843. A unique voice in angling literature. Arnold Gingrich said that if he was put ashore on the proverbial desert island, he would beg to keep only one book besides Walton, and that would be Scrope. At my income I have no business owning a first edition, but I do, and it's pure pleasure. W.C. Stewart, The Practical Angler (1857). The pathbreaking work that made the case for casting and fishing upstream. Thaddeus Norris, The American Angler's Book (1864, 1865). A combination of lively wit, tales, essays, and sound angling information. The best American angling book of the nineteenth century. Halford vs. Skues. Their books form the classic dry fly vs. submerged fly debate. John McDonald (editor), The Complete Fly Fisherman: The Notes and Letters of Theodore Gordon (1947). Essays and letters written late 19th - early 20th century by Theodore Gordon. Filled with useful information, anecdotes, history, and personal asides by a thoughtful and intelligent man who for a century - and perhaps well into the future - has been the most significant influence on the dry fly in America. A.J. McClane, The Practical Fly Fisherman (1953, 1975). Just what the title says. Lee Wulff, The Atlantic Salmon (1958 and later editions). You want one of the later editions for the full course, applicable not only for salmon fishing but many other things too. Datus C. Proper, What the Trout Said (1982). Fundamental work about designing trout flies by keeping in mind trout behaviors, and not human preferences. Obviously builds on Marinaro's A Modern Dry Fly Code (1950), which should also be on any reasonable "greatest" list.
Quashnet's Paul H. Young Rod Database has photos and descriptions of over
480 PHY Co. rods, plus catalogs, accessories, etc. Thank you to all
who continue to send me PHY rod photos and info.
|
||||
|
|
||||
cdmoore |
Good points, Flyman. Nice list, Quash. | #8 | ||
|
I like, I like. This is the essence of the post! You've got it. Please keep it coming folks...you KNOW you're out there.
"If you finish in 7 days, I'll pay you for 10. If you finish in 10 days, I'll pay you for 7." ~Ballykissangel
|
||||
|
|
||||
tedgolden |
#9 | |||
|
In no particular order:
The Trout and the Fly, Gottard and Clarke What The Trout Said, Datus Proper Anatomy of a Fisherman, Traver -After reading, my life profoundly changed. "It's his fault," my wife has mentioned more than once. How to Catch Fishermen, Zern - Or anything else by Zern. Joys of Trout, Gingrich Trout, Bergman Fishless Days, Angling Nights, Hackle Wonderful World of Trout, Fox Modern Dry Fly Code, Marinaro Practical Fly Fisherman, Wetzel Matching the Hatch, Trout, Schwiebert Caddisflies, LaFontaine Selective Trout, Swisher & Richards I think these books and authors had the most influence on me. |
||||
|
|
||||
bobbeegee |
Most important to me | #10 | ||
|
This is a list of books I've enjoyed over the years, and still do.
Wouldn't say they're the most important fly fishing books of all time, but they are important to me personally. The Fish and the Fly by John Atherton Fishing Bamboo by John Gierach Trout Madness by Robert Traver Fishing the Dry Fly As a Living Insect by Leonard Wright Trout by Ernest Schwiebert The River Why by David James Duncan Classic Rods and Rodmakers by Martin Keane Clorado Classic Cane by Dick Spurr and Michael Sinclair Heddon The Rod with the Fighting Heart by Michael Sinclair Any book by Harry Middleton Others, but don't wish to bore you any further. Bob Go Heels!!! |
||||
|
|
||||
dr knuemann |
#11 | |||
|
Dr K: I edited this from a single block of text. Thanks for your contribution to the discussion!
Last Edited By: cdmoore 08/13/2009 14:23.
Edited 2 times.
|
||||
|
|
||||
pcg |
#12 | |||
|
A couple volumes that have been left out:
Hatton's "Rod Crafting," a seminal work that in importance eclipses 75% of the texts mentioned so far; Campbell's "Classic & Antique Fish-Fishing Tackle," a flawed work but one of great ambition & breathe; and Schwiebert's double volume "Trout," another somewhat less than perfect work but one that has resonated for decades for almost all fishermen. What a magnificent work! I think it may have been mentioned once above. I too think that the goal of "Top Ten" is difficult. Regardless, we're lucky that there are so many excellent tackle-related books. |
||||
|
|
||||
Short Tip |
#13 | |||
|
For flyfishing, which I think was the genesis of the thread, I'd have to go with the giants already listed, Walton, Cotton, Berners, Gingrich, LaBranche,
MacDonald, Atherton, Halford, Skues. Two I would add which I didn't see above would be Emlyn Gill's "Practical Dry Fly Fishing" and Charles
Wetzel's "American Fishing Books", an impossibly rare but absolutely wonderful book. My copy is a quarto sized reprint which was printed in an
edition of 75 (!) and is much easier to obtain than a self-published (and self-bound!) original. This book deserves a wider reprinting. (After I posted this I
searched around and found a later edition of 500 by Meadow Run in 1990 - So get one!)
"When all the rods and a lot of reels, lines, leader boxes, et cetera, had been sold, the gang paid at the cashier's
window for what they'd bought and then made a bee line for the rug room to test their rods. I put mine together, tested it for a moment or so, and then
started to show it to men I knew. Not a man was interested in my rod. They all, without a single exception, tried to get me to look at theirs. Extraordinary,
how self centered most men are. Have you noticed it? "
Last Edited By: Short Tip 08/13/2009 19:38.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
creakycane |
#14 | |||
|
Can't think of many that have not been mentioned!
Ronald's book is remarkable in that it was one of the first books to attempt to classify insects in a serious way. You guys might like "The Fly" by Dr Andrew Herd, Medlar Press if you haven't seen it - great history along the lines of Gingrich and McDonald. Its out now in paperback..... I would say in terms of impact, the greatest might be: Antique category - 5th Edition of Complete Angler (Walton with Cotton addition) Modern Category: A River Runs Through It, Norman Maclean Whether the impact is/was positive or negative is up to the individual. Writers were talking of polluted streams and crowded waters in England in the 1700's! Study to be Quiet! ____________ Interestingly, in northern Spain, a book called The Astorga Manuscript was written by Juan de Bergara, outlining a series of wet fly patterns using coq de Leon feathers, in1624 (before Walton's birth). It had limited circulation until the 20th century, but it's amazing how modern the book is - I believe Mr Preben Jacobsen published a translation in English Spanish and Dutch in the 80s' - Paul Morgan still had some copies quite reasonably. |
||||
|
|
||||
Short Tip |
#15 | |||
!
"When all the rods and a lot of reels, lines, leader boxes, et cetera, had been sold, the gang paid at the cashier's
window for what they'd bought and then made a bee line for the rug room to test their rods. I put mine together, tested it for a moment or so, and then
started to show it to men I knew. Not a man was interested in my rod. They all, without a single exception, tried to get me to look at theirs. Extraordinary,
how self centered most men are. Have you noticed it? "
|
||||
|
|
||||
creakycane |
#16 | |||
|
Thanks Short Tip - I think that is the from Winchester Cathedral where Walton is buried - along the Itchen.
Always makes me think of Paul Purcell of Chiloquin OR, from whom I'm sure more than a few of you bought books..... |
||||
|
|
||||
Armchair Angler |
#17 | |||
|
John Waller Hills, as was mentioned, discussed many-many books from Dame Julia up to 1921. What he did was interesting in that he highlighted those books that
changed or advanced how fly fishing was practiced. The first guy to really get into details about insects, as Creaky says, was Ronalds, he credited Steward
for turning our attention to casting upstream, Halford for dry flies, etc. I'm not sure if we have advanced all that much (in how we fish) since Hills
1921 publication. Like Quash says, Datas Propers; book What the Trout Said, was a unique look at how fish "see's"
things . Marinaro wasn't the 1st, but he really studied light and surface impressions. These were important contributions but I don't know if they
really changed how fly fishing is now practiced. We are tying very sparse, in the film, emergers or parachutes now. This is pretty big - who can be credited
with that development? Perhaps tying with extraordinary materials - synthetics?
The way I see it, the major contributions (or maybe the change in evolution of fly fishing), since Hills book is the environmental aspect. I'd suggest that we now care far more about a healthy fishery than the numbers of fish brought to the creel. I don't know who should get the most credit for this but Roderick Haig Brown should be in the running (Lee Wullfe too?) Another angle may be simply to look at who has done most to keep the sport alive and thriving for this past generation? A River Runs Through it has been mentioned, I'd agree. I'd also say the books by Gierach and Lyons (pick any of them) - their columns in the Fly Fishing mags, I'm sure lead many people like me to their books and hooked them for life. |
||||
|
|
||||
Booman2 |
#18 | |||
|
Paul Purcell bought about 600 books from my library once, when the military moved me at the wrong time. Great guy and lover of fine books. Had the good fortune
to retire on a fine Oregon river. He and the great Joe Wilcox took a lot of my money over the years. Some of my favorites in no order except the first: Izaak
Walton, The Complete Angler. I like either the Bethune edition which contains a great bibliography of early American angling books, or the leather bound
Nonesuch Press limited edition, 1929, which includes Walton's "Lives" and miscellaneous writings. After 450+ editions since 1653, it still has
much to say about why we fish. Arnold Gingrich, The fishing in Print. Written by the long time editor of Esquire, Mr. Gingrich's book reviews the best, and
keeps me interested in buying those titles I don't have. Roderick Haig-Brown, A River Never Sleeps. Just a great read by a fine
, great fisherman and
conservationist. I'm fortunate to have one of his flies and a few of his personal letters. Once owned one of his rods. Jock Scott (Donald Rudd), game Fish
Records. Much more than just the records. Martin Keane, Classic Rods and Rodmakers. The book that saved bamboo, made Marty some money and changed my life. John
McDonald, The Origins of Angling. John Brown, The American Angler's Guide, 1849. Locks early information in place. A. J. McClaine, The Wise Fishermen's
Encyclopedia, 1951. Pearls from the pen of Stoner and others. Much on rod building, steelhead fishing and more. Section on ferrules is wonderful. Cheap.
Hewitt, A trout and Salmon Fisherman for 75 years. George LaBranche, A dry Fly and Fast Water, and The Salmon and the Dry Fly. Drewitt, Hardy Brothers, The
Masters, the Men and Their Reels. Locks in the history of Hardy and has fine photos. Anything and everything by Hills, Skues and Halford.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Gnome |
#19 | |||
|
Oppians "Halieuticks" 1721 Translation One of the finest pieces of prose ever written about fish and fishing Gervaise Markham , A Pleasure of Princes 1609 my copy is a later printing done in 1654 The first purpose built dry fly and one of the finest descriptions of match the hatch ever put to paper. This is a work that does not get the recognition it is due. Mascall late 1500's The Arte of Angling He was one of the major influence behind Waltons first edition of the Complete Angler. Odd how Piscator and Venator are the main characters in a work that predates Walton by almost 100 years. Ronalds "A flyfishers Entomolgy" 1836 For all of the reasons stated earlier. Thaddeus Norris "American anglers guide" 1865 2nd edition Hoflands "British Anglers Manual" 1839 Jack Dennis "Western Trout fly tieing Manual Volume 1" This work tuned my tieing up and was one of the best on how to tie and is still one of the best "How to's ever done" "Classic rods and Rod Makers" Keane AJ Campbell "Classic and Antique fly fishing Tackle" Even though a bit flawed a work that for awhile drove my collecting bug at warp speed. And inspired me to do a Color Companion to complement what was done by Campbell and Keane. Which Resulted in my Authoring of Rod Crafting. And last but not least would be any of the angling works done by Henry Van Dyke with a special nod to The work titled Fishermans luck as good of a book on why we fish as has ever been done. Jeff
Last Edited By: Gnome 08/14/2009 11:02.
Edited 3 times.
|
||||
|
|
||||
gmflyfish |
10 Books | #20 | ||
|
I guess I struggle with books versus authors
1. Dana S. Lamb 2, Ernest Schweibert 3. Nick Lyons 4. Izaak Walton (any edition) 5. Bergman 6.A. J. McClane 7. Dave Hughes 8. marty Keane 9. Gary LaFontaine 10. Frank Sawyer Hard for me to seperate into titles as these authors have meant a lot to me and I have all they have written. Gregg |
||||
|
|
||||